Selling Sports Equipment

>> Sunday, November 22, 2009

I did find a couple of examples of the kind of sign that I referred to in a previous post, the sign for a commercial establishment that used the word "selling" to describe their activities, as in "Selling All Kinds of Gemstones".

As I kept an eye out for the sort of sign I wanted, I realized that they were not as common as I had remembered. But here is an example that I found, and a nearby sign that might be a more ambiguous use of the -ing ending.

Maybe this second sign indicates a usage that is, as Cambodians often say: "same, same, but different."

Read more...

I Don't Think She Knows What Her Shirt Says ...

>> Friday, November 20, 2009

.... nor what it might imply to some people.

Tons of used clothes are imported into Cambodia every year and sold. They fill a huge market for cheap, durable clothing.

It comes as no surprise to see a Cambodian wearing a very expensive, name-brand shirt. He will tell you he paid a dollar or two for it.

Since most of the t-shirts are from the States or are meant for that market, slogans are many.

They might proclaim allegience to a college football team, patriotic love for country, devotion to Jesus or cynicism about the US government. Or residence in an obscure town.

I doubt even English-speaking Cambodians know what is at stake in these colorful public assertions. I once saw a T-shirt that said: "West Point Plebe." The young man wearing it was fit enough to be a Plebe, but he was busy unloading bananas from the provinces.

Other shirts made in China or Taiwan (actually who knows where they are made) are covered with mis-spelt and mainly nonsense English words and phrases; there seems to be a kind of status thing going on with the English language and clothing in Asia; it is certainly easy to make fun of their attempts. An alternate hypothesis is that groups of English lettering are used as aesthetic elements, as one might use a butterfly or a flower in the visual composition that is the shirt. No message is in fact intended. I favor this interpretation. :)

But the young lady at the top of this post is wearing a shirt whose message seems ambiguously provocative (the split E is interesting). I would bet she has no idea what it might mean. I doubt the shirt is from the States, but who am I to say. I have been gone so long. As to what she might think about it, I would never dare ask her.

She was the ticket taker on a ferry from Kampong Chnnang Province town to the small town and island of Kampong Klang. Nice young lady. Very business-like and serious about her work. Did not stop to chat with the customers and certainly not the young men; she practiced the kind of reserve young, unmarried women do in Cambodia, despite her public job. A normal, young, Cambodian lady, without the slightest sense of what her very provocative shirt might be interpreted as saying.

The lady at the right (she was a waitress, and probably the daughter of the owner of a small noodle shop in Kampong Cham) was wearing a shirt, that was definitly not bought and worn in the US, not part of a bulk consignment of used clothes that made it all the way to Cambodia, and is just a spelling error. :)

Read more...

A Mis-Translation

>> Thursday, November 19, 2009

I told myself that one thing that I would not do on a blog that focused on my encounters with the Khmer language was make fun of local translations. If I want them, they are not difficult to find, but reveal nothing except idiosyncratic inadequacy or simple misunderstanding. However, last weekend I found an example at an old temple that I cannot resist posting though it does not appear at first glance to be very illuminating in general.

Some mis-translations (Is that the right term to use? We will have to see if it sticks) are revealing, especially if they tend to recur.

A common one is the shop house sign. They will very often say in English: 'Selling Gemstones' or 'Selling Cakes'.

'Selling' as it is used here is clearly not a gerund, its use rather aims to translate the business description into the present continuous tense. When I read the English, I have this feeling that the owner is trying to communicate the existence of an on-going activity, rooted in the past, continuing even as we look, and which will optimistically continue in the future. Kind of nice. But that may just be me because the accompanying Khmer is usually the simple verb and direct object: something you would find no good reason to translate as other than: 'Sell Gemstones.' (In Khmer it is not a given that an unstated but understood 'we' is included.) In the Khmer no direct evidence that continuity of the business is being communicated.

An adverbal phrase is available in the Khmer language to indicate continuous action (there is no conjugation of verb forms! Hurray!) but since it is not used on signs, it appears that the Khmer preference is simply to indicate, for a store, something like: 'Sell Chicken Feet'.

I'll see if I can take a picture. Shouldn't be too hard. And that would not be making fun. We need to figure out why they do not simply say: 'Gemstones' or 'Cakes'.

But with that over-long introduction, here is the recent find, the one I could not resist posting. At a Chenla-era temple (circa 700 A.D.) on whose inside door frame is painted the Khmer admonishment to take off one's shoes before entering, we find an English translation (or mis-translation) painted.

They had to physically shut my mouth. :) I can't even begin to speculate about that word choice: shoes, sandles, saucers: the synonym progression does not work, even if you take 'saucer's as inventively metaphorical or poetic (same thing?).

The ancient temple towers are beautiful (there are two, the site is named Prey Nokor) and typical of their sort. A more modern Khmer Buddhist ediface has grown up around it. As is often the case in Cambodia, next door to the modern temple is a school. Kids wandered onto the grounds to buy fruit and candy from the sellers there. (No 'Selling Candy' signs :) Two old ladies who sold incense sticks to the visitors, visitors who were expected to put aside their saucers as they entered the small sanctuary to offer the burning sticks,chatted with me, and is so typical that it can't be offensive, explained how poor and old they were (angling for a contribution, even if I bought no sticks).

I visited this temple during a recent trip to Kampong Cham Province (where I got my motorcycle repaired :). I had seen the sign to the temple many times from National Route 7, north of Kampong Cham town and across the Mekong bridge on my many trips to Ratanakiri, but had never stopped in. I was glad that this time I did, though the road was deeply rutted after the long rainy season, which meant that the dusty and bumpy 15 kilometers took about 45 minutes on my newly repaired motocycle. But I left with that unsolved puzzle: 'saucers' for 'foot-gear'. I do love Cambodia.




Read more...

Use and Repair ... not Make

>> Wednesday, November 18, 2009

As I sat in the motor-cycle shop (see my last post) getting all those little needed repairs and interventions completed that I had so long neglected, I wrote some notes to myself on the question whether analytic use might be made of the disctinction between, well, 'use' and 'make' ('create, manufacture') in the context of locally produced language for imported technology.

And as I watched with growing appreciation, the easy relationship between the owner of the repair shop and his son (part coaching, part teaching, part directing: 'get this' or 'get that'), I mused on what kind of language of use, repair and description might arise in cases where the physical technology (being used, described and repaired) is so much more easily imported than is the technical language that supports it (or where there is a significant enough lag for local linguistic choices to take root).

"So anyway."

(I wrote. Who knows why?)

"I had this insight, 'revelation' :), that one place to look for (watch?) how language changes would be by tracking how the language of everyday life accomodates new technology: the technology that Cambodians themselves have not invented, but which entered their lives in an unmissable way.


"Though they did not invent telephones, cars, computers, or motorbikes, they use them, and they repair them. Repair is not a one person activity. It normally requires (at least for cars and motorbikes) some level of co-ordination of effort. Co-ordination of effort requires the cooperation facilitation function of language.

"Think of Wittgenstein's description of bricklayers building a house: 'brick', which use might produce the same outcome as 'bring me a brick.' (You don't need to know what a brick is, what it is made of, how to make one, in order to respond properly to the command: 'brick'. But to build a house collaboratively, you need something like the command "brick" and the behaviors correlated to its use.)

"But communication is not strictly required in all cases for repair. I have seen phone repairmen focused on a single handphone, working alone. However, even working alone, he will need a clearly developed language of object and action, if, for example: a problem arises requiring consultation; tools are shared between independent repairmen ("give me that solder iron for a minute"). And even when the repairman is completely independent (fully competent to recognize and to solve the problems that he meets, fully tooled out and self-sufficient), he (never seen a female repairperson here :) will need to be trained.

"The telephone will have been broken down in pieces for him by his trainer and named, their functions may not need to be understood as fully as the maker might understand them, but the repairmen should understand their typical modes of failure (and thus the signals of proper functioning), and what to do about them, and to our point here, how to talk about them. A shared language of description, functioning and action will be necessary.

"Why would I expect to learn anything by looking there?

"1) The intrusion of these new technologies are recent (less so for motorcycles and cars, more so for handphones and computers). It is very unlikely that a fully articulated language of understanding and repair would have been imported, fully mature, at least for handphones, computer science has been taught for years at the university level, so that will be different. The language that emerges in everyday usage would inevitably have elements where (through metaphorical appeal) bits of Khmer would be attached to the bits and pieces of technology and to the activities surrounding its use, sale and repair.

"It would be interesting to see where and how the Cambodians would linguisically cut up the phone (as users and repairmen, not creators). Might be surprises there.

"2) Some of the language in use would inevitably be imported, but I would expect that the majority of the language used would be Khmer words and phrases which have settled meanings, long histories and common usages already. It would be fascinating to investigate if the conceptual surround of these words and the connotations that they (in their normal use) give rise to widen our understanding of the kinds of things (modes of engagement) that can be at stake or are available in the wider culture. What kind of window into current Khmer culture might such a look provide?

"3) It seems likely that similar but independent efforts (use, teaching and repair), coming to flower nearly simultaneously in geographically dispersed locations (like Phnom Penh and Battambang) without the help of repair manuals, without textbooks or technical schools, and without a long engagement with the technology to develop (institutionalize) a common language of description and function, you might find different sets of words (and perhaps regulating conceptions) used for common phrases like: 'bring me that wrench', 'this Nokia screen is damaged' in different places. What might be made of that?"

Read more...

Wittgenstein and Motorcycle Maintenance

>> Monday, November 16, 2009

Took my motorcycle to be worked on in Kampong Cham the other day. Found a Cambodian on National Route 7, before you get to town, who specializes in larger bikes (mine is a medium-sized Honda CL 400 cc; 25,000 Cambodian kilometers and counting :).

As almost all Cambodian businesses are, this one is a family business. His wife and two sons can be seen lubricating my motorcycle's chain in the picture below.


As I watched the father and his son work on my motorcycle, it struck me how easily the son would find the tools that the father needed. It was not just a surprise because the shop was not very well organized -- though it appeared that the disorganization was deceptive, the kid would invariably get to the right tool (though maybe not the right size) very quickly. But where did the language for all those different tools come from?

That question led to a stream of thought about how language grows to accomodate technological change and availability. (And to a distinction between technology that you discover/build/make and technology to which you are a relative late-comer, but which you use. Make versus use. Can one find interesting differences in linguistic outcomes (and causal patterns) by focusing on this distinction? And how would you go about it?)

I was reminded of the passages in Wittgenstein's Philosophical Investigations about bricks and slabs (more in a later post if the off-hand thought makes any sense or contribution to this line of inquiry). The interesting aspect to this is that there is no tradition of building motorcycles (or computers, handphones, or cars and trucks) in Cambodia, though the business of repairing them has become very important (handphone shops, used handphone offerings, the entire infrastructure has proliferated madly in a very short period of time).

As I sat there I wondered how the language evolved to make it possible to coordinate the various actions of repair (and to facilitate the teaching of repair). Even the tools needed are imported, they are used, not made.

(Take the simple ink pen. Cambodians never produced any. They don't now. They still call it by the French word Bic, which of course is not French for pen, but rather the first major manufacturer of pens that the Cambodians encountered. Reminding me when I was a kid, we never said "make a photocopy", we said "Xerox it". Could have been another machine, but never mind that. :)

But motorcycles get repaired, even though the stance of Cambodians toward motorbikes and motorcycles is that of user and not creater (builder or maker). The language of repair and parts might be (in part) imported, borrowed, but much is likely to be invented (metaphorically) to build the local linguistic institutions of repair and use.

In the back of my mind, these could be places where one might do some very interesting investigation.​


Read more...

View My Stats

  © Free Blogger Templates Autumn Leaves by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP