Showing posts with label Mis-translation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mis-translation. Show all posts

Selling Sports Equipment

>> Sunday, November 22, 2009

I did find a couple of examples of the kind of sign that I referred to in a previous post, the sign for a commercial establishment that used the word "selling" to describe their activities, as in "Selling All Kinds of Gemstones".

As I kept an eye out for the sort of sign I wanted, I realized that they were not as common as I had remembered. But here is an example that I found, and a nearby sign that might be a more ambiguous use of the -ing ending.

Maybe this second sign indicates a usage that is, as Cambodians often say: "same, same, but different."

Read more...

A Mis-Translation

>> Thursday, November 19, 2009

I told myself that one thing that I would not do on a blog that focused on my encounters with the Khmer language was make fun of local translations. If I want them, they are not difficult to find, but reveal nothing except idiosyncratic inadequacy or simple misunderstanding. However, last weekend I found an example at an old temple that I cannot resist posting though it does not appear at first glance to be very illuminating in general.

Some mis-translations (Is that the right term to use? We will have to see if it sticks) are revealing, especially if they tend to recur.

A common one is the shop house sign. They will very often say in English: 'Selling Gemstones' or 'Selling Cakes'.

'Selling' as it is used here is clearly not a gerund, its use rather aims to translate the business description into the present continuous tense. When I read the English, I have this feeling that the owner is trying to communicate the existence of an on-going activity, rooted in the past, continuing even as we look, and which will optimistically continue in the future. Kind of nice. But that may just be me because the accompanying Khmer is usually the simple verb and direct object: something you would find no good reason to translate as other than: 'Sell Gemstones.' (In Khmer it is not a given that an unstated but understood 'we' is included.) In the Khmer no direct evidence that continuity of the business is being communicated.

An adverbal phrase is available in the Khmer language to indicate continuous action (there is no conjugation of verb forms! Hurray!) but since it is not used on signs, it appears that the Khmer preference is simply to indicate, for a store, something like: 'Sell Chicken Feet'.

I'll see if I can take a picture. Shouldn't be too hard. And that would not be making fun. We need to figure out why they do not simply say: 'Gemstones' or 'Cakes'.

But with that over-long introduction, here is the recent find, the one I could not resist posting. At a Chenla-era temple (circa 700 A.D.) on whose inside door frame is painted the Khmer admonishment to take off one's shoes before entering, we find an English translation (or mis-translation) painted.

They had to physically shut my mouth. :) I can't even begin to speculate about that word choice: shoes, sandles, saucers: the synonym progression does not work, even if you take 'saucer's as inventively metaphorical or poetic (same thing?).

The ancient temple towers are beautiful (there are two, the site is named Prey Nokor) and typical of their sort. A more modern Khmer Buddhist ediface has grown up around it. As is often the case in Cambodia, next door to the modern temple is a school. Kids wandered onto the grounds to buy fruit and candy from the sellers there. (No 'Selling Candy' signs :) Two old ladies who sold incense sticks to the visitors, visitors who were expected to put aside their saucers as they entered the small sanctuary to offer the burning sticks,chatted with me, and is so typical that it can't be offensive, explained how poor and old they were (angling for a contribution, even if I bought no sticks).

I visited this temple during a recent trip to Kampong Cham Province (where I got my motorcycle repaired :). I had seen the sign to the temple many times from National Route 7, north of Kampong Cham town and across the Mekong bridge on my many trips to Ratanakiri, but had never stopped in. I was glad that this time I did, though the road was deeply rutted after the long rainy season, which meant that the dusty and bumpy 15 kilometers took about 45 minutes on my newly repaired motocycle. But I left with that unsolved puzzle: 'saucers' for 'foot-gear'. I do love Cambodia.




Read more...

This Mother's Child

>> Tuesday, November 3, 2009


I was having breakfast this morning, just down the street from where I live in Phnom Penh. As I ate my noodle soup, I noticed for the first time the name of the small family-run restaurant (as most in Cambodia are) across that small street: Restaurant My Kid.

The Khmer version of the name is Ko-in Mah (my phonetization), which is written in Khmer above the English. Had a nice conversation with a man who had sat down next to me about whether there is a better English translation of the Khmer original. I told him that the English, taken by itself, did not seem to do the work needed. In English, "kid" is informal, it lacks any great emotional weight, linked to the neutral 'My' it does not naturally bring to mind anything about the mother-child relationship as I thought the Khmer did (an argument I will try to make below). Moreover at some distance it can bring to mind the idea of a young goat!

'Mah' (or Ma) is a shortened form for mother in Khmai. It is what a small child most likely would call her mother when the child is happy, hungry, worried, or needs attention: the word brings to mind (rises out of) the whole complexity of the reationship between the Khmer morther and her child.

The mother will herself use the word 'Mah' as a pronoun, in reference to herself. Not as a mother might say in English, using some very formal, probably stern third person voice when she speaks to her child: "Your mother is very disappointed in you," but almost always The English version of this usage is rare, but possible. The Khmer mother will not use the colder, more formal "I" (knom), but "Mah" to refer to herself. She will use it like a first-person pronoun. By comparison, the English word "mother" is more distant, almost clinical, a lexical entry. (But we, in English, do this sometimes: "Mother loves you!" his mother told him. But to a child incapacitated by extreme youth, or an older child, by severe illness).

The English "My" implies a simple statement of possession, and though the phrase "My kid" is not as empty of deep emotional connotations as "My book" might be, unless it is clear that you wrote the book or that it changed your life, or you are in an argument over whose it really is. "My kid might find easy competition (for different reasons of course) with the phrases "My dog" or "My car" in attempts to show emotional connection. For example, "That's my kid (dog, car)" often provides more than simple information. It can indicate pride or love though by pointing to the specifity of something done in the moment by the , rather than focusing on the specific. "That's my boy" in English, might be more intense, intensely proud for example, it might more clearly connote real love and connection.

The Khmer noun "Ko-in" is the word used almost exclusively to designate that person who is one's own child (rather than just any kid, or children in general), so again, this word brings to mind (for a Cambodian) all the dependency, loyalty, wonder and pain of the relationship, and, at not a very great distance, the fact that most Cambodian children will say, without hesitation or reservation: "I can never disappoint my mother, she has sacrificed so much for me."

Their conjunction is so very interesting. "Mah" acts as an possessive pronoun, indicates ownership or possession, the centrality of child in the phrase brings into view everything that it means in Cambodia to be the child in a Khmer family. The reason it is translated as "My Kid" instead of "Mother Kid" is because in English we do not use a relational tag (like mother, brother, father, or child) as a personal pronoun, in Khmer it is ubiquitous.

Is there a better translation of this bit of Khmer into English? I tentatively offered: "Mother's Child" or "This Mother's Child", which in English might help to bring to mind the centrality, if not the intensity of the relationship and help us know that it is the mother of that child who is speaking. Not about just any child. Not just about MY child. But the child of a mother who, with the mother of the child, share such a close relationship that the child calls the mother what the mother calls herself: "Mah."

Note: In general I do not want this blog to devolve into a laughing gallery showing Cambodian translations of English that seem silly, even laughable. But there are some translations, unique, non-recurring, that may be illuminating. As I hope that this one is. One's that recur may be even more illuminating.

We do need to talk a lot more about the whole raft of personal pronouns that are used in Khmai. They take the logic of German's Sie and du, or the French's Vous and tu to an extreme.

"Hey little sister what have you done?

Hey little sister who's the only one?
Hey little sister who's your superman?"

Billy Idol

Read more...

View My Stats

  © Free Blogger Templates Autumn Leaves by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP