Showing posts with label Bizot. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bizot. Show all posts

Dried or Smoked Fish? Your life might depend on it.

>> Wednesday, November 4, 2009


Bizot, in his auto-biographical work "The Gate" describes a tense scene at the French Embassy in Cambodia. Expatriates and Khmer refugees have holed up there in the aftermath of the Khmer Rouge take-over of Phnom Penh. It is 1975, Lon Nol has fled to the United States, his US-supported regime has collapsed; US forces are withdrawing from Vietnam under the cover of a peace agreement that barely cloaks their defeat. Cambodia will soon be forgotten and left to the Khmer Rouge. Tens of thousands will be executed, millions will die of over-work, malnutrition and un-treated disease.

In the Embassy, staff face their captors and possible executors for the first time. No one knows what will happen. Will their diplomatic immunity be respected? What will happen to the Khmer who crowded in with the expats, friends and colleauges, most with no foreign passport? (Some of the drama of this episode is communicated by the movie: "The Killing Fields".) More immediately is the question of food and water for everyone. Bizot describes this first meeting with Nhem, who is the commander of KR forces in Phnom Penh, to discuss these issues. Tension immediately rises over what Bizot implies is a translation error.

The French Ambassador asks for dried fish and rice and water (of course he asks in French, not English). His interpreter asks for what is most easily translated back into English as smoked fish, not dried fish.

"The atmosphere in the room grew tense," Bizot writes. "Yet what could be more legitimate than our modest requests?" The Ambassador knows something has gone wrong, but does not know what. The interpreter repeats the request "more gently". Bizot immediately sees the difficulty. He is asking for smoked fish, not dried fish: "a request as inappropriate as if we had requested smoked salmon from people who had been surviving on bread and water. Trai ngiet had become a rare commodity. It was a sought-after specialty of the Great Lake, a complicated preparation using only one or two types of extremely expensive fish." (Modern smoked Cambodian fish are pictured above).


Bizot intervenes and says that actually all that is needed is "for the fish to be dry, 'snguot', or edible in any way. This question is unimportant." The Khmer Rouge look relieved (face has been saved, there was no way they could get smoked fish, and no way to say that they could not), the Ambassador is happy. For Bizot this is a transformational moment. He becomes the primary intermediary between the Embassy and the Khmer Rouge commanders and one of the few allowed outside the Embassy to look for other expatriates and to scavenge for tinned and other foods. He becomes an important witness to what became of Phnom Penh in the immediate aftermath of the Khmer Rouge takeover. (The second picture in this post shows some of the salted fish offerings at the O'Russei Market).

And the interpreter? Bizot says "I had caused him to lose face." Of the 'mistake' Bizot says: "the confusion was commonplace, if not inevitable in such a pressured situation."

I have a different take. Bizot says that the interpreter knew the "Khmer language perfectly". Of course he did, that is not the question, the question is how well did he know French. I suspect, given the job that he had, the elevated plane on which he worked, he knew that as well as one might a second language (as I assume that it was), certainly well enough to know the difference between smoked and dried fish in spoken French. He made no mistake; he knew what he was doing.

What I imagine is that this high-level interpreter working directly with the French Ambassador could not imagine that the Ambassador might be satisfied with what was peasant food, dried fish. If he was going to eat something other than fresh fish, how could the interpreter facilitate anything less than trai ngiat! I imagine that in his mind that was his job, to take care of the Ambassador, and that meant, in this case, trai ngiat, not trai sgnuot. (The second picture above shows modern salted fish offerings at the market).


If Bizot had had more presence of mind, he might have asked the interpreter whether he thought that in fact simple dried fish might be okay, allowed the interpreter to acknowledge that yes, of course, dried fish would be fine and then allowed the interpreter to rephrase the question to the KR. No one would have lost face, the aim would have been achieved the KR satisfied. The question put to the interpreter would have given him permission to move away from his own definition of what his job demanded, and if the question had been put in French, it would have had best effect. (They did not ask for salted fish, pictured above and to the left).

But how could one fault Bizot? In such a situation one would have been terrified, the near-term question of food and water was the focus, but the elephant in the room had to be the question that could not be asked: "Are you going to kill us all?"

In the end, the expatriates with passports, and the Khmer who had foreign passports or who could get French passports forged for them, as many did, got out through Thailand. The vast majority of the Khmer who had taken refugee in the Embassy, slipped out at night, or, if they stayed until the end, were taken out by the KR, the vast majority executed.

Bizot does not tell us what happened to the interpreter (he gets another mention late in the book). But I feel a deep sadness for him. His 'mistake' did not increase the likelihood that he would be executed, if taken by the KR he was already doomed by his work with the French -- and his family too. He is less than a footnote to history, but I believe that he made no mistake. I believe that he was doing the job to the best of his ability. Ambassadors do not eat dried fish. If they eat any at all, it must be the best. He was taking care of his Ambassador in the only way he knew how, the way that his upbringing and culture demanded.

He was publicly humiliated, but if things had not happened in this way, it is possible that we would not have gotten Bizot's first hand accounts of his conversations with Nhem, or his observations of Phnom Penh after entry of the KR.

Bizot, Francois. "The Gate", translated from the French by Euan Cameron. The Harvell Press, London, 2003, pages 158-9

(All pictures taken at O'Russey Market, Phnom Penh, November, 2009)

Read more...

The Main Point in My Encounters With the Khmer Language

>> Sunday, October 18, 2009

In Francois Bizot's auto-biographical work, "The Gate", he writes:

"I hated the idea of talking to the Khmers in French; the sentences seemed flat and meaningless, for it is not only words that differ from one language to another, but also the ideas they translate, different ways of thinking and speaking."

We encounter this aside as Bixot relates his jungle confrontations with Duoch, the murderer, the torturer, his prison-keeper, and eventually a kind of friend

It is perhaps no large or novel insight these days.

The fact that there are significant problems in translation across languages is now accepted even in common culture, if only to acknowledge that some words are "difficult to translate" or "untranslateable". What gives so much weight to Bizot's observation is that it was no idle comment. He was fluent in Khmer. Duoch was fluent in French. They could have easily spoken in either language as they confronted each other daily in the jungle clearing that served as a Khmer Rouge jail and where Bizot was staked to the ground. Bizot  says: "it occurred to me that we had only ever spoken in Khmer".

Bizot's life depended on his ability to convince Duoch that he was not a CIA operator as he had been accused when captured, his only means of defense were his own words, offered and repeated, the answers he could give to the questions that Duoch asked. Bizot was a French researcher, a long-time resident of Cambodia, whose focus of study was the practice of Buddhism and the Ancient Khmer civilization -- and nothing more. Somehow he had to prove this to Duoch, in the middle of the jungle, to prove this without witnesses and without documents, with only the consistency between what he said at one time, and at another, as his salvation.
His life is literally on the line and depends on the result of three months of interrogations that occur in the midst of the Cardoman Mountain jungle in the early 1970's. "I could not explain in my own tongue what I had to say to my torturer. The bonds gradually forming between us depended entirely on our capacity to understand each other on common ground, and thus could be done only in his language."

Today, in late 2009, Duch is on trial for the thousands of murders he oversaw as the head of the infamous Toul Sleng prison in Phnom Penh during the Khmer Rouge period in Cambodia. Bizot is the only westerner to have survived imprisonment by the Khmer Rouge; he was the first witness in Duoch's trial.

This idea, this hypothesis, is what brought me to Cambodia in 1992. I aimed to discover how difficult the UNTAC organized transition to democratic rule might be, given traditional Khmer forms of social solidarity and competition. I assumed that these would be reflected in their language, a language created, sustained and altered by its users to facilitate that solidarity and to underwrite their own forms of cooperation and competition. I wanted mostly to see if I could find places in the Khmer language where words reflected concepts that made possible ways of behaving that might not be accessible to the English language and vice-versa.

I wanted to learn how the Cambodians sustained their solidarity and how it broke down from the point of view of its own conceptual structure, reflected in its language. I thought, perhaps naively, that points of access into these mysteries might be achieved by seeing how and to what extent the western conventional language of democracy might or might not find purchase in Cambodia, within the Cambodian culture as reflected in its language (and the patterns of solidarity, competition and behavior it made possible).

(Democratization requires institution building. Institutions suited to that form of governance, aimed to ameliorate and make less possible the autocratic rule and deadly factional cleavage that were typical of the exercise of political power in Cambodia, needed to introduce a new language, I assumed, a language that would not find an easy match to the words, and concepts behind them, then available in the Khmer language. New modes of political competition would require embedding new ways of thinking, need to promote new forms of solidarity and competition, new political behaviours to supplant outdated ones. At least this is how I thought about it.)

This blog cannot point in any way to even partial answers to the questions that brought me to Cambodia, but I do hope to record some of my more interesting encounters (and inferences from those encounters) with the Khmer language on my long road to try to get some idea what the answers to the these questions might be, or to finally accept that the questions were flawed from the beginning.

Read more...

View My Stats

  © Free Blogger Templates Autumn Leaves by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP